(Copied from superuser)
With SSDs getting cheaper and more mature, I am thinking of getting some for off-site backups. I would store system images and media backups on it, updated weekly-monthly. The drives would be rarely moved (although some shock tolerance would be welcome), stored at ~20C and powered on only to update the backups (so weekly/monthly). Considering all this, would I be better off with an external SSD or HDD?

(SSDs - consumer grade MLC/TLC, Samsung T5, HDDs - consumer/enterprise grade (not much of a diff anyway) WD, both in under 1TB varieties)

  • Since you have copied your question from Super User without asking to have it migrated, go a head and delete your SU question. No use in keeping it up over there.
    – Cfinley
    Commented Sep 20, 2017 at 15:40

1 Answer 1


Assuming price is not a concern, neither one has much of an advantage over the other for your purposes.

  • A powered-down laptop hard drive is reasonably shock-resistant: the 500g rating is roughly equivalent to falling off a table onto a concrete floor.
  • A SSD has a much higher random-access speed than a hard drive, but backup and restore are mostly sequential-access operations, where SSDs don't have anywhere near as much of an edge.
  • Hard drives have better long-term powered-off behavior. A hard drive pulled out of storage will either power up properly, providing access to all its data, or not power up properly, requiring work by a data-recovery company to provide access to all the data. A powered-off SSD will gradually lose data in an unrecoverable fashion after a few years. This is mostly not an issue for you, since you plan to store the drives at low temperature (which reduces the data loss rate), and you plan to power them up periodically to update the contents.
  • SSDs handle being turned off and on much better than hard drives do, but again, this is mostly not an issue: being power-cycled 50 times a year is well below the limits for a hard drive.

The big advantage hard drives have is still price: a 1TB external hard drive is about $60, while a similar-sized SSD is around $300.

Whichever way you choose to go, make sure your backup plan can handle the failure of one of your external drives. There's no point in having a backup if the backup itself is a weak point.

  • thanks, very insightful. price is always a factor, but I prefer the added peace of mind with SSD shock resistance and maturing controllers. I am still combing through the models, but 3D TLC seems to be a better option device-wise than (3D) MLC. I looked through HDDs as well, but didn't find anything innovative or exciting apart from helium drives, which are oriented at higher capacities than I need
    – 4004
    Commented Sep 21, 2017 at 21:06

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.